If I own the original release and the Game of the Year Edition can I earn trophies twice? September 10, 2019 17:42 Updated Follow No, Trophies are not earnable twice, both editions are the same app. Related articles Are the DLCs / Updates on the disc, or do I have to download them? I Platinumed the game, will I receive a special avatar? The game appears smaller than my screen (black bars). I bought The City That Never Sleeps but I can’t play it.